Independent Insurance Agency — Greeneville, TN

One Bad Storm. One Wrong Policy. Don’t Find Out the Hard Way.

Most people don’t check their coverage until it’s too late. We’re the independent agency at 822 Tusculum Blvd that shops Erie, Progressive, and other top carriers — so you never pay for coverage you don’t need or miss the coverage you do.

We're Open Now — Call for Immediate Help
4.9 stars — Over 100 Google Reviews
Erie Insurance — A+ Rated (A.M. Best)
Locally Owned Since 2000
4.9-Star Google Rating
Talk to a Real Person — Every Time
A+ Rated (A.M. Best)
Licensed in Tennessee
100+ Five-Star Reviews
Independent Agent — We Work for You
Serving Since 2000
0 + Years Serving Greeneville
0 + Five-Star Google Reviews 0 /5 Average Google Rating
0 + Communities Served

How Working With Us Is Different

Three steps to coverage that actually fits.

1

Tell Us What You Need

Call, stop by, or fill out our quote form. We’ll ask the right questions so we understand your full picture — not just what box to check.

2

We Shop Multiple Carriers

As an independent agency, we compare options from Erie, Progressive, and other markets. You see the real choices — not just one company’s answer.

3

You Choose With Confidence

We walk you through the differences in plain English. No jargon, no pressure. And when life changes, we’re here to adjust your coverage.

Find Out If You’re Covered
No obligation No credit check Takes 2 minutes

Why Greeneville Chooses Vallie Insurance

We’re not the biggest agency in East Tennessee. We’re the one that picks up the phone when you call and knows your name when you walk in.

  • Independent Agency We represent you, not one insurance company. That means real choices.
  • Erie Insurance Partner — A+ Rated Erie holds A.M. Best’s highest financial strength rating and retains over 90% of its customers year after year.
  • Serving Greeneville Since 2000 Over two decades of protecting families, businesses, and farms across Greene County.
  • 4.9-Star Google Rating Over 100 five-star reviews from real clients who trust us with their most important assets. Read our reviews →
  • Claims Advocacy When something goes wrong, we don’t hand you an 800 number. We walk you through the claim and fight for your settlement.
Meet the Team

Why Choose an Independent Agent?

See the difference between a captive agent (locked to one carrier) and Vallie Insurance.

One Carrier vs Many Carriers

Captive Agent

Captive agents sell ONE company's policies. If their rates go up, you're stuck.

Vallie Insurance

Independent agents like Vallie shop Erie, Progressive, and more — we find the best fit for YOU.

Call Center vs Local Office

Captive Agent

Big carriers route you to call centers. You explain your situation to a stranger every time.

Vallie Insurance

At Vallie, you get Kelley McCray — same agent, same number, same office at 822 Tusculum Blvd.

Cookie-Cutter vs Custom Coverage

Captive Agent

Captive agents follow their company's script. One-size-fits-all doesn't fit everyone.

Vallie Insurance

We build your coverage from the ground up — mixing carriers to get the right protection at the right price.

Price-Only vs Value-Focused

Captive Agent

Online quote tools show you the cheapest option. Cheapest ≠ best when a claim happens.

Vallie Insurance

We show you what you're actually getting for your money — and where cutting corners could cost you thousands.

Claims: On Your Own vs On Your Side

Captive Agent

When you file a claim with a big carrier, you're a policy number in a queue.

Vallie Insurance

When you file through Vallie, we advocate for you personally. Your claim is our priority.

Featured Partner

Erie Auto Insurance — Cheaper Isn’t Always Better

Most national carriers write 6-month policies and raise your rate after any change. Erie is different.

12-Month Policy

No 6-month surprises. Your rate is locked in for a full year — not 180 days.

ERIE Rate Lock®

Your rate stays the same year after year, even after a claim. Only YOU can change it.

YourTurn® Rewards

Safe drivers earn up to $260/year (teens) or $130/year (adults). No penalty for opting in.

Multi-Policy Discount

Bundle auto + home and save. Most clients save 15–25% with Erie multi-policy pricing.

See All Erie Auto Advantages

When It Mattered Most, We Were There

Real scenarios, real outcomes. This is what having a local agent means.

Hail Storm

Roof Totaled After Spring Storm

A Greeneville family discovered their roof was destroyed after a hailstorm. Their Erie policy included Guaranteed Replacement Cost — meaning they got a full new roof, not a depreciated check.

Full roof replacement covered
Auto Accident

Rear-Ended With Rate Lock

A Mosheim driver was rear-ended at a stoplight. Their claim was paid quickly, their car repaired — and thanks to ERIE Rate Lock®, their premium didn’t go up at renewal.

Rate stayed the same after claim
Business Loss

Water Damage Closed the Shop

A burst pipe shut down a Tusculum Blvd business for three weeks. Their BOP policy covered property damage plus lost income while they couldn’t open.

Property + lost income covered

How Protected Are You? Take the 60-Second Quiz

Answer 5 quick questions and we’ll tell you where you might have coverage gaps.

When was the last time you reviewed your insurance coverage?

Do you have an umbrella policy that extends beyond your auto/home limits?

If your home was destroyed tomorrow, would your policy cover the full cost to rebuild?

Do you have a separate flood insurance policy?

Does your family have life insurance that would cover at least 10 years of income?

0/15

Get a Free Coverage Review
No obligation Takes 5 minutes Talk to a real agent

Proudly Serving East Tennessee

Our office is on Tusculum Blvd in Greeneville, but we serve clients throughout the region.

Greeneville
Mosheim
Tusculum
Chuckey
Baileyton
Afton
Mohawk
Bulls Gap
Rogersville
Morristown
Johnson City
Kingsport

Don’t see your town? We write policies throughout Tennessee. Give us a call — if we can help, we will.

Get Your Free Quote in 3 Easy Steps

No obligation. No pressure. A licensed agent will reach out as soon as possible.

No credit check No personal info sold Talk to a local agent
1 Coverage 2 Details 3 Contact

What type of insurance do you need?

Help us find the best rate

How should we reach you?

Insurance Tips & Local News

Practical advice from your Greeneville insurance team.

View All Posts

The Worst Time to Find a Gap in Your Coverage Is After a Claim

A 5-minute call with a local agent can save you thousands when something goes wrong. No obligation, no pressure, no call center — just an honest review of what you have and what you might be missing.

Mon–Tue, Thu–Fri: 9 AM – 5 PM | Wed: 9 AM – 3 PM